Rugby America

Rugby News & Views From an American Perspective

Quantity Over Quality?

by Ted Hardy

Note: This article was originally published on November 16, 2012. Some minor adjustments to the article have been made to make it current.

From time to time, I like to dig into the archives and find an article that was written over a year ago that is relevant to events that are going on in American rugby today. A little over a week ago I wrote the article Every Community Deserves Rugby and it seemed to really strike a chord. As a community, we all want this for America, so that led me to look at ways to make it happen. So, while searching in the archives yesterday I found this article which is quite similar in promoting the goal of a rugby club in every community. This one takes a bit of a different angle in that it mostly refers to the need for more adult rugby clubs as a vehicle for the creation of more youth rugby clubs. I thought it would be nice to share.

I hope you enjoy.

As Americans, we want to be successful at everything. Let me correct that, we want to be the best at everything. Call it what you will, but that is how most of us are wired and it isn’t a bad thing at all. Nothing wrong with being competitive and striving for greatness whether you’re in business, sports, or mowing your lawn.

This concept certainly applies to rugby, where America has made major strides, but in comparison to the major rugby playing nations… we fall considerably short on success. This is all relative, since the USA would easily beat the majority of rugby playing nations in the world. However, we’re in the business of being the best, so until the USA is hoisting the Webb Ellis, we will continue to chase the goal.

The one true sustainable pathway to the promised land of the IRB Top 5 is the development of grassroots rugby. I’ve said it many times before and I’ll continue to preach it in the future. It is going to be a long and hard road, but it is the only true way. Talks of professional leagues and sending players overseas will only get us so far. What is needed is a massive player base in which to draw upon athletes. Otherwise any success will only be short lived and fleeting. By massive player base, that means youth, high school, college, and even adults. We need opportunities for all age groups. We have roughly 100,000 registered rugby players in America. When that number approaches 1,000,000 I guarantee that our national teams will see improved results.

This begs the question… do we need quality over quantity or is it the other way around? That really shouldn’t even be a question right? Quality should always win out. In regards to this conversation, I’m not so sure. Perhaps we, the American rugby community, have to rethink our strategy. We should be looking for quality and quantity with possibly an edge being given to quantity because the sport needs to be passed along by any means necessary.

There are some very well established and high quality rugby clubs in America. They have earned their place with hard work and sacrifice by generations of players. I would never dream of downplaying their success. They are the cornerstone of the rugby community and most metropolitan areas in America have a longstanding rugby club in the area. These same clubs, along with so many others, have been vital to the growth of youth rugby in America.

Now is the time to begin to spread our reach into every community, not just the big ones.

How many new rugby clubs have cropped up in your area in the last five years? Ten years? By new rugby clubs, I am referring to men’s and women’s teams. The growth of youth and high school rugby is well documented and growing. That growth has much to do with the adult playing base in America. As active players become Old Boys/Girls they often start youth and high school programs in their respective towns and communities. So, you can see how a massive increase in the adult playing base can pay off dividends down the road. If the goal is a youth rugby program in every community, I think we need a lot more adult rugby clubs to help foster and support that goal.

Back to the above question. How many new clubs/teams? Unless we’re talking about sevens, there haven’t been many new clubs established. Now, how many clubs do you know that have folded? Probably about the same number or sadly more. Back in the old days of Rugby Magazine (you know… when it was something that showed up in your mailbox), they used to have a yearly breakdown of the number of clubs in each territory. I always found it interesting, but a bit worrying that even 7-8 years ago there was a bit of stagnation in regards to the growth of adult club rugby.

(Side note… when I first thought of reprinting this article I contacted USA Rugby looking for club data from the past 5-10 years. I never received any reply.)

There are many factors that play into club rugby… funding, access to facilities, and a host of others that have been giving administrators headaches for decades. It is just not that easy to start or maintain a club. In this day and age, USA Rugby and the rugby community should be making it easier to grow the game, not the other way around. In fact, a pretty good argument could be made that spreading the word of rugby should trump all other goals. This is an area where I see a major opportunity for improvement.

Our quest for the immediate gratification in regards to success has blinded many of us. We’ve all heard the arguments about rugby communities that support multiple teams. Some support the idea of providing a variety of opportunities for players of all levels. Others would rather see all but one team eliminated to make the strongest competitive team possible. I appreciate the determination and respect it, but it is blind ambition. It’s perfectly fine to strive to be the best, but not at the cost of the long term goal of growing the game of rugby at all levels in the United States. Growing the player base has a profound impact on the money invested in the sport and has proven to be a positive factor on the growth of youth and high school rugby. Both things that we want in America.

USA Rugby has done a pretty solid job supporting and promoting growth in the youth and high school sector, but I worry that the approach they have taken with club rugby may cost us playing numbers down the road. Their focus on club rugby has been centered on Elite rugby, championships, and playoff scenarios that ultimately serve only a small portion of the playing population.

What could be done to help support and foster the growth of new clubs in America? Certainly some brave souls are needed to bite the bullet and start new clubs. Perhaps a mechanism that allows players associated with new clubs to also participate with more competitive clubs while the new club is getting established? Could USA Rugby waive some fees for new clubs that also establish youth programs?

In the end, a youth program in every town should be our goal. We’re on our way. To help get there, we need a lot more adults introduced to the game. Adults that will go on to create and support more youth programs.

What do you think?


One comment on “Quantity Over Quality?

  1. lachy
    January 16, 2014

    Given the size of your country there is no reason that you would not become the top team.Would your team be as dominant as your b’ball team – no ,though i would expect a win ratio around the 70- 100% range dependant on whom you play.will you get there though.In my life time possibly, but more likely not. If you develop your players from a young age and have enough ethnic players you may get to the top4 in another 5-6 world cups time. What do you need for success, a change in players financial expectations ,unfortunately the want for big time cash is engrained in your sports culture. Amateur comps to develop young players.emphasise skill over brawn.You need ethnic players, polynesian or african american. as shown in other sports you play dominated by white boys, you do not cut the mustard as a dominating team rather than just a competitive one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on January 16, 2014 by in Rugby News.

RSS Rugby Wrapup

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Planet Rugby

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

RSS Rugby Redefined

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
%d bloggers like this: